On South Pleasant View Road, crews broke ground October 16 on Scholar's Ridge, a 102-home subdivision built through a county program. That program's first subdivision sold its homes for $315,000 to $325,000. Along Highway 67, Heritage Grove's builder lists home-and-lot packages starting at $450,000. In September 2026, the median residential sale in Sheboygan County was $315,000.
That puts Plymouth's new construction at two price points: one right at the county's resale median, the other about $135,000 above it. Between roughly $325,000 and $450,000, neither project has anything to offer. That's the range where existing Plymouth homes won't compete with anything new from either subdivision, and it should shape how both buyers and sellers read this market over the next two years.
The resale number both projects are measured against
The Wisconsin REALTORS Association's September 2026 report, released October 22, puts Sheboygan County's median residential sale price at $315,000 for September 2026. That's unchanged from September 2025. The county had 97 sales that month, down from 106 a year earlier. Average days on market fell from 71 to 67, and months of inventory held at 3.9. These are county-wide residential figures, and Plymouth is one market inside them.
A flat median, fewer sales, and steady inventory point to a market that's holding its price without speeding up. For context, the same September 2026 report has Washington County's median at $425,000 and Ozaukee County's at $496,000. If you're comparing Plymouth against West Bend or the Ozaukee lakeshore towns, the county medians are more than $100,000 apart before you look at a single house.
Plymouth also hasn't added many homes in a long time. The city's November 2024 housing study counted only 225 housing units built since 2010 and found just four rental listings in August 2024. In the employer interviews for that study, participating employers reported more than 175 open positions, and respondents put the single-family price their employees could afford at roughly $180,000 to $250,000. Against 225 units in roughly 14 years, the 102 homes at Scholar's Ridge and 119 lots at Heritage Grove add up to more than 200 new single-family homes.
Scholar's Ridge follows a model that has already sold out once
Scholar's Ridge is the third subdivision built through the Sheboygan County Economic Development Corp.'s Housing Initiative, on a 32-acre site on Pleasant View Road. It's paid for through the Forward Fund, which Johnsonville, Kohler Co., Masters Gallery Foods and Sargento each put $2 million into. Sheboygan County added $2 million in American Rescue Plan Act money, and the City of Plymouth is also a funding partner. WHEDA lent the project $3.4 million through its Infrastructure Access Loan program, which, as The Daily Reporter reported, had never before been used for single-family homes in Wisconsin.
The best guide to Scholar's Ridge pricing is Founders' Pointe in Sheboygan Falls, the fund's first project. In 2024, SCEDC told the Badger Institute that Werner Homes was building those houses at 1,300 to 1,500 square feet, each with three bedrooms, two bathrooms and a two-car garage, and selling them for $315,000 to $325,000. The same article explained that the homes sell as close to construction cost as possible and that sale proceeds go back into the fund to pay for the next round of building. SCEDC sells the homes directly through its own website using a buyer selection process it runs itself.
All 54 Founders' Pointe homes have sold. According to The Daily Reporter's October 2026 coverage, 72% of buyers were first-time buyers, 30% had relocated to Sheboygan County, and the residents work for 54 different employers across the county. A second neighborhood, Founders' Pointe Neighborhood, has 41 homes planned and is expected to be finished in spring 2027. SCEDC's Plymouth housing page has a sign-up for Scholar's Ridge updates.
Founders' Pointe's $315,000 to $325,000 range sits right on the September 2026 county median. If Scholar's Ridge prices come in near that precedent, Plymouth will add new homes at the same price as the county's typical resale house, and SCEDC's process, not the open market, will decide who buys them.
Heritage Grove starts $135,000 higher
Heritage Grove is Neumann Developments' subdivision along Highway 67. The City of Plymouth's February 5, 2026 Plan Commission minutes show a preliminary plat for 119 single-family lots in four phases, with parkland and stormwater ponds. Seehafer News reported in July that the first phase was expected to include about 43 homes, available in 2027. When it announced both projects, the city said it "looks forward to these new neighborhoods and the families that will eventually call them home."
Harbor Homes is building in Heritage Grove, and its community page lists home-and-lot packages starting at $450,000. It also lists 20 floor plans, from 1,610 to 2,355 square feet, with three- and four-bedroom options, plus lookout or walkout lower levels on some lots. Base plan prices on the same page start at $289,200 for the 1,610-square-foot Saybrook. The $450,000 package figure includes the lot, so that's the number to compare against resale.
That $450,000 entry point is also above the $425,000 Washington County median for September 2026. A West Bend buyer looking north will find new construction in Plymouth priced in the same range as resale homes back home.
What the gap means for resale
| Scholar's Ridge (Founders' Pointe precedent) | Plymouth resale (county median, Sept. 2026) | Heritage Grove | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price reference | $315,000–$325,000 (2024) | $315,000 | Packages from $450,000 |
| Size reference | 1,300–1,500 sq ft | Varies | 1,610–2,355 sq ft |
| Sold through | SCEDC's own selection process | Open market | Harbor Homes |
| Timing | Broke ground Oct. 16, 2026 | Available now | First phase expected in 2027 |
How much new competition a Plymouth seller faces depends on the list price. Near $315,000, an existing home will share a price with Scholar's Ridge, but those homes reach buyers through SCEDC's process rather than the open market, so they aren't directly competing for every shopper. Between about $325,000 and $450,000, neither subdivision has a new home on the price sheet. From $400,000 to $450,000 and up, a resale home will be listed against Heritage Grove's brand-new floor plans and walkout lots, so condition, updates and the lot itself will carry more weight than they do near the median.
For buyers, the same gap works the other way. If your budget falls between the two subdivisions, Plymouth's existing homes are where you'll be shopping for the next couple of years, and inventory has been holding at 3.9 months county-wide. Our earlier look at what drives days on market in Plymouth covers how pricing and condition affect how fast a home sells, and the Plymouth neighborhood page has the broader picture.
Quick answers
What will Scholar's Ridge homes cost? The closest guide is Founders' Pointe in Sheboygan Falls, where homes sold for $315,000 to $325,000 in 2024. You can sign up for updates on SCEDC's Plymouth page.
Is Heritage Grove part of the same program? No. Heritage Grove is a private subdivision by Neumann Developments, and Harbor Homes lists home-and-lot packages there starting at $450,000.
Do the county figures describe Plymouth exactly? No. The WRA numbers cover all residential sales in Sheboygan County for September 2026. A home-by-home comparison in your part of Plymouth will give you a more accurate number.
If you own a Plymouth home and want to know whether its price puts it next to Scholar's Ridge, next to Heritage Grove, or in the range between them, Craig Kasten can compare it against recent local sales and both new subdivisions. Start with a free home valuation and consultation.